computer screen with words DRUG WAR BLOG bird icon for twitter bird icon for twitter


Alternative Medicine as a Drug War Creation

a philosophical review of The Quantum Doctor by Amit Goswami

by Brian Ballard Quass, the Drug War Philosopher






March 14, 2020



n "The Quantum Doctor"1, Amit Goswami discusses the different uses of so-called alternative (or "integral") medicine versus allopathic medicine, in an effort to claim that each has its proper place in the medical world.

Update: May 28, 2025

What he fails to point out, however, is that this distinction between homeopathy and allopathy is really a creation of two related forces: the Drug War and capitalism, and is not fundamentally a result of differing medical views. If there are different medical ideologies at play here, they themselves were fostered, if not created, by the Drug War (its stark limitations on what may be legally prescribed) and capitalist practice (the need to find one-size-fits-all cures that will be most profitable to the doctor and pharmaceutical companies that provide them).

Amit Goswami, for all his valuable insights, makes the mistake of almost every other author when it comes to discussing these subjects: he ignores the role of the Drug War in influencing the "facts on the ground," writing as if the American healthcare system existed on a level playing field when it comes to deciding what sorts of medical treatment we should value and pursue. The fact is that literally all of the most powerful and efficacious "mood medicines" of Mother Nature have been outlawed by the Drug War, so that we can only guess what sorts of treatment Americans would choose if they were actually given the freedom to make such a choice.

Amit's goal seems to be to promote "alternative" therapies in a way that will not be a turn-off to allopathic doctors, by saying that each treatment style (homeopathy and allopathy) has its usefulness. A better approach would be to argue for complete medical freedom via the abolition of drug-war restrictions, after which a doctor will be encouraged to use all possible approaches, without attempting to recognize or draw a sharp line between the medicines based on the philosophical systems that their use seems (to us at least) to presuppose. As Amit himself points out, some allopathic drugs function homeopathically (in preventing illness). Amit, however, claims that "alternative" therapies do not function rapidly -- but, again, he is reckoning here without the Drug War. The fact is that many natural (alternative) "mood medicines" DO function rapidly. The problem is that they are illegal and simply cannot be used.

Related tweet: March 29, 2023


Anti-homeopaths usually champion one-size-fits-all treatments, like SSRIs. They do not like substances that "merely" make the depressed feel good. That's why they dislike laughing gas and coca. They want therapies that work according to reductionist criteria.



Author's Follow-up:

May 28, 2025

picture of clock metaphorically suggesting a follow-up





Re-reading this essay five years later, I am struck by the presumption of folks like Amit Goswami when they tell us that alternative treatments for mental and emotional improvement work slowly. This is simply not true. What Amit means to say is that all the fast-acting pharmacological interventions (like phenethylamines2, DMT3, laughing gas4, the coca leaf5, an opium pipe6, etc.) have been outlawed, and that THEREFORE, alternative approaches work slowly. This is not just to quibble, either. When we fail to mention this caveat, we are giving the Drug War a huge Mulligan for the evil that it causes, by killing minorities, destroying the rule of law, and sharply limiting our healthcare choices. Fortunately, for Amit, his followers have been brainwashed just like himself: they are already used to pretending that drug prohibition is a natural baseline for human existence and so they remain blind to the obvious downsides of that anti-scientific and ultimately racist policy. If this were not so, then Amit would have been laughed out of the room when he first tried to tell his readership that alternative medicines work slowly. ("Hey, is this guy KIDDING us???!")

By ignoring the role of drug prohibition in limiting our healthcare options, Amit is helping to normalize drug prohibition. And he is not alone. Almost all authors reckon without the Drug War today: they ignore the obvious relevance of outlawed drugs to their topics of choice. And so authors write about suicide without mentioning the fact that we have outlawed all drugs that could cheer one up in real-time7; they write about shock therapy without mentioning the fact that we have outlawed all the drugs that could make it unnecessary8; they write about the mind-body problem, without mentioning the fact that we have outlawed all the substances whose strategic use could enlighten us on that topic9. William James urged us to investigate the nature of reality with the help of such substances10, but modern philosophers ignore that "call to arms" in fealty to Drug War orthodoxy, which tells them that so-called "drugs" can have no positive uses whatsoever11. And so modern non-fiction authors are magicians, really. They are all adepts at the trick that I call "The Great Disappearing Drug War!" -- whereby they wipe drug prohibition and its endless real-world downsides from the public mind. And what is the collective result of this legerdemain? The public attitude becomes: "Drug War? WHAT Drug War?"

Almost all non-fiction writers employ this magic trick, but CNN Correspondent Lisa Ling really outdid herself when it comes to ignoring the Drug War and its downsides. She produced a whole documentary on Chicago gun violence in which she never even mentioned the Drug War, even though it was liquor and drug prohibition that brought gunfire to the streets in the first place12! There are magicians like this on both the left and the right. In "A People's History of the United States of America," progressive historian Howard Zinn never even mentions the Drug War13. In "Birth of the Modern," conservative historian Paul Johnson is silent on that subject as well14. Houdini would have been jealous at this ability on the part of our writers to redirect the human mind away from the glaringly obvious.

Incidentally, this is why I am turned off by all things "New Age." New Agers, at least as I define that term, are those who seek to achieve the psychological benefits of drug use through politically correct means, such as crystal-gazing, seances, meditation, purging, the "mindful" use of medicinal teas, and so forth. This is not bad in itself, of course -- one has to work with what one has in the real world -- but almost all New Age mavens (like Amit himself, alas) are never honest about the way that the Drug War has starkly limited our ability to achieve our desired psychological outcomes. By remaining silent on this point, they are helping to normalize drug prohibition. Nay, their silence about the Drug War implies that they are in favor of that disastrous public policy. And so when I am amongst a group of New Agers, I feel as if we are all playing a game of make-believe, that we have all taken some kind of childish oath that we will never talk about "drugs" and that it would be rude to point out the power of such substances to help us achieve our end goals viz. enlightenment and inspiration.



Notes:

1 Goswami, Amit, The Quantum Doctor: A Physicist's Guide to Health and Healing, (up)
2 PiHKAL: A Chemical Love Story, UC Berkeley Center for the Science of Psychedelics, (up)
3 Gibbons, Alex, DMT Trip Reports - Experience What It’s Like Taking 5 Meo Dimethyltrptamine, 2020 (up)
4 Quass, Brian, Why the FDA should not schedule Laughing Gas, 2023 (up)
5 Mariani, Angelo, Coca and its Therapeutic Application, Third Edition, Gutenberg.org, 1896 (up)
6 Brereton, William, The Truth about Opium / Being a Refutation of the Fallacies of the Anti-Opium Society and a Defence of the Indo-China Opium Trade, Anna Ruggieri, India, 2017 (up)
7 Quass, Brian, Why Americans Prefer Suicide to Drug Use, 2025 (up)
8 Quass, Brian, Electroshock Therapy and the Drug War, 2020 (up)
9 Quass, Brian, The Kangaroo Courts of Modern Science: an open letter to Mike Jay, author of Emperors of Dreams: drugs in the nineteenth century, 2025 (up)
10 Quass, Brian, A Philosophical Review of 'The Varieties of Religious Experience': How William James failed to connect the dots, 2025 (up)
11 Quass, Brian, How Harvard University Censored the Biography of William James, 2025 (up)
12 Quass, Brian, Open Letter to Lisa Ling, 2022 (up)
13 Zinn, Howard, A People's History of the United States: 1492 - present, New York, 2009 (up)
14 Johnson, Paul, The Birth of the Modern, Harper Collins, New York, 1991 (up)



People

about whom and to whom I've written over the years...

Alexander, Lamar
Letter to Lamar Alexander
Barrett, Frederick S.
The common sense way to get off of antidepressants
Why the Drug War is Worse than you can Imagine
Benaroch MD, Roy
Open Letter to Roy Benaroch MD
Bloom, Josh
Science is not free in the age of the drug war
Buchanan, Julian
Finally, a drug war opponent who checks all my boxes
Chalmers, David
David Chalmers and the Drug War
Chelmow MD, David
How the US Preventive Services Task Force Drums Up Business for Big Pharma
Chomsky, Noam
Chomsky is Right
Chomsky's Revenge
Noam Chomsky on Drugs
Cline, Ben
Open Letter to Congressman Ben Cline, asking him to abolish the criminal DEA
Close, Glenn
Glenn Close but no cigar
Cossin, Daniel
How AI turned William James into a Drug Warrior
De Quincey, Thomas
The Therapeutic Value of Anticipation
Dick, Philip K.
Drug Laws as the Punishment of 'Pre-Crime'
Doblin, Rick
Constructive criticism of the MAPS strategy for re-legalizing MDMA
Is Rick Doblin Running with the Devil?
Why Rick Doblin is Ghosting Me
Ellsberg, Daniel
Drug Warriors Fiddle while Rome Gets Nuked
Falcon, Joshua
Drugs are not the enemy, hatred is the enemy
Floyd, George
The Racist Drug War killed George Floyd
Fort, Charles
The Book of the Damned
Fox, James Alan
The Invisible Mass Shootings
Friedman, Milton
How Milton Friedman Completely Misunderstood the War on Drugs
Fukuyama, Francis
Open Letter to Francis Fukuyama
Gibb, Andy
How The Drug War Killed Andy Gibb
Gimbel, Steven
Heroin versus Alcohol
Glaser, Gabrielle
Open Letter to Gabrielle Glaser
Glieberman, Owen
Open Letter to Variety Critic Owen Glieberman
Glover, Troy
Open letter to Professor Troy Glover at Waterloo University
Goswami, Amit
Alternative Medicine as a Drug War Creation
Gottlieb, Anthony
Open Letter to Anthony Gottlieb
Grandmaster Flash, musician
Grandmaster Flash: Drug War Collaborator
Griffiths, Roland
Depressed? Here's why you can't get the medicines that you need
Open Letter to Rick Doblin and Roland Griffiths
Gupta, Sujata
The Mother of all Western Biases
Hammersley, Richard
Open Letter to Richard Hammersley
Handwerk, Brian
How National Geographic slanders the Inca people and their use of coca
Harris, Kamala
Why I Support Kamala Harris
Harrison, Francis Burton
Screw You, Francis Burton Harrison
Hart, Carl
Open Letter to Dr. Carl L. Hart
What Carl Hart Missed
Harvey, Dennis
How Variety and its film critics support drug war fascism
Heidegger, Martin
Heidegger on Drugs
Hogshire, Jim
I've got a bone to pick with Jim Hogshire
Opium for the Masses by Jim Hogshire
What Jim Hogshire Got Wrong about Drugs
Hurley, Vincent
Open Letter to Vincent Hurley, Lecturer
Hutton, Ronald
Drug Dealers as Modern Witches
James, William
How the Drug War is Threatening Intellectual Freedom in England
Keep Laughing Gas Legal
The Criminalization of Nitrous Oxide is No Laughing Matter
William James rolls over in his grave as England bans Laughing Gas
Jefferson, Thomas
A Misguided Tour of Monticello
How the Jefferson Foundation Betrayed Thomas Jefferson
How the Monticello Foundation betrayed Jefferson's Legacy in 1987
Jefferson
The Dark Side of the Monticello Foundation
Jenkins, Philip
'Synthetic Panics' by Philip Jenkins
Jenkins DA, Brooke
Prohibitionists Never Learn
Kant, Immanuel
How the Drug War limits our understanding of Immanuel Kant
How the Drug War Outlaws Criticism of Immanuel Kant
Kastrup, Bernardo
How Bernardo Kastrup reckons without the drug war
Kenny, Gino
The Right to LIVE FULLY is more important than the Right to DIE
Kirsch, Irving
Brahms is NOT the best antidepressant
Klang, Jessica
All these Sons
Kotek, Tina
Regulate and Educate
Koterski, Jospeh
America's Blind Spot
Kurtz, Matthew M.
How Scientific American reckons without the drug war
Langlitz, Nicolas
Why the FDA is not qualified to judge psychoactive medicine
Lee, Spike
Spike Lee is Bamboozled by the Drug War
Leshner, Alan I.
How the Drug War Screws the Depressed
Lewis, Edward
Psilocybin Mushrooms by Edward Lewis
Ling, Lisa
Open Letter to Lisa Ling
Locke, John
John Locke on Drugs
Maples-Keller, Jessica
Hello? MDMA works, already!
Margaritoff, Marco
In Defense of Opium
Open Letter to Margo Margaritoff
Marinacci, Mike
Psychedelic Cults and Outlaw Churches: LSD, Cannabis, and Spiritual Sacraments in Underground America
Martinez, Liz
Replacing antidepressants with entheogens
Mate, Gabor
In the Realm of Hungry Drug Warriors
Open Letter to Addiction Specialist Gabor Mate
Sherlock Holmes versus Gabor Maté
McAllister, Sean
How to Unite Drug War Opponents of all Ethnicities
Mithoefer, MD, Michael
MDMA for Psychotherapy
Mohler, George
Predictive Policing in the Age of the Drug War
Morgan, Cory
Canadian Drug Warrior, I said Get Away
Naz, Arab
The Menace of the Drug War
Newcombe, Russell
Intoxiphobia
Nietzsche, Friedrich
Nietzsche and the Drug War
Nixon, Richard
Why Hollywood Owes Richard Nixon an Oscar
Noakes, Jesse
Americans have the right to pursue happiness but not to attain it
Nobis, Nathan
Top 10 Problems with the Drug War
Nock, Matthew K.
How Harvard University Censored the Biography of William James
Nutt, David
Majoring in Drug War Philosophy
O'Leary, Diane
Open Letter to Diane O'Leary
Obama, Barack
What Obama got wrong about drugs
Offenhartz, Jake
Libertarians as Closet Christian Scientists
Pearson, Snoop
Snoop Pearson's muddle-headed take on drugs
Perry, Matthew
Drug War Murderers
Matthew Perry and the Drug War Ghouls
Pinchbeck, Daniel
Review of When Plants Dream
Polk, Thad
How Addiction Scientists Reckon without the Drug War
Pollan, Michael
Michael Pollan on Drugs
My Conversation with Michael Pollan
The Michael Pollan Fallacy
Rado, Vincent
Open Letter to Vincent Rado
Reuter, Peter
The problem with Modern Drug Reform Efforts
Rovelli, Carlo
Why Science is the Handmaiden of the Drug War
Rudgeley, Richard
Richard Rudgley condemns 'drugs' with faint praise
Sabet, Kevin
Why Kevin Sabet's approach to drugs is racist, anti-scientific and counterproductive
Sanders, Laura
Science News Continues to Ignore the Drug War
Santayana, George
If this be reason, let us make the least of it!
Schopenhauer, Arthur
Ego Transcendence Made Easy
What if Arthur Schopenhauer Had Used DMT?
Schultes, Richard Evans
The Drug War Imperialism of Richard Evans Schultes
Segall PhD, Matthew D.
Why Philosophers Need to Stop Dogmatically Ignoring Drugs
Sewell, Kenneth
Open letter to Kenneth Sewell
Shapiro, Arthur
Illusions with Professor Arthur Shapiro
Smith, Wolfgang
Open letter to Wolfgang Smith
Unscientific American
Smyth, Bobby
Teenagers and Cannabis
Sotillos, Samuel Bendeck
In Defense of Religious Drug Use
Stea, Jonathan
The Pseudoscience of Mental Health Treatment
Strassman, Rick
Five problems with The Psychedelic Handbook by Rick Strassman
What Rick Strassman Got Wrong
Szasz, Thomas
In Praise of Thomas Szasz
Tulfo, Ramon T.
Why the Drug War is far worse than a failure
Urquhart, Steven
No drugs are bad in and of themselves
Vance, Laurence
In Response to Laurence Vance
Walker, Lynn
Ignorance is the enemy, not Fentanyl
Walsh, Bryan
The Drug War and Armageddon
The End Times by Bryan Walsh
Warner, Mark
Another Cry in the Wilderness
Watson, JB
Behaviorism and the War on Drugs
Weil, Andrew
What Andrew Weil Got Wrong
Wells, HG
HG Wells and Drugs
Whitaker, Robert
Mad at Mad in America
Whitehead, Alfred North
Whitehead and Psychedelics
Willyard, Cassandra
Science News magazine continues to pretend that there is no war on drugs
Winehouse, Amy
How the Drug War Killed Amy Winehouse
Wininger, Charley
Getting off antidepressants in the age of the drug war
Wuthnow, Robert
Clodhoppers on Drugs
Zelfand, Erica
Open Letter to Erica Zelfand
Zinn, Howard
Even Howard Zinn Reckons without the Drug War
Zuboff, Shoshana
Tune In, Turn On, Opt Out



computer screen with words DRUG WAR BLOG


Next essay: The Totally Unspoken Truth About Drugs
Previous essay: Surprise Drug Test!

More Essays Here




Some Tweets against the hateful war on drugs

The "scheduling" system is completely anti-scientific and anti-patient. It tells us we can make a one-size-fits-all decision about psychoactive substances without regard for dosage, context of use, reason for use, etc. That's superstitious tyranny.
The proof that psychedelics work has always been extant. We are hoodwinked by scientists who convince us that efficacy has not been "proven." This is materialist denial of the obvious.
For those who want to understand what's going on with the drug war from a philosophical point of view, I recommend chapter six of "Eugenics and Other Evils" by GK Chesterton.
"Politics is the art of looking for trouble, finding it everywhere, diagnosing it incorrectly, and applying the wrong remedies." -- Groucho Marx
There's more than set and setting: there's fundamental beliefs about the meaning of life and about why mother nature herself is full of psychoactive substances. Tribal peoples associate some drugs with actual sentient entities -- that is far beyond "set and setting."
If MAPS wants to make progress with MDMA they should start "calling out" the FDA for judging holistic medicines by materialist standards, which means ignoring all glaringly obvious benefits.
Drug prohibition is superstitious idiocy. It is based on the following crazy idea: that a substance that can be misused by a white young person at one dose for one reason must not be used by anybody at any dose for any reason.
When people tell us there's nothing to be gained from using mind-improving drugs, they are embarrassing themselves. Users benefit from such drugs precisely to the extent that they are educated and open-minded. Loudmouth abstainers are telling us that they lack these traits.
I'm told antidepressant withdrawal is fine because it doesn't cause cravings. Why is it better to feel like hell than to have a craving? In any case, cravings are caused by prohibition. A sane world could also end cravings with the help of other drugs.
Was looking for natural sleeping aids online. Everyone ignores the fact that all the stuff that REALLY works has been outlawed! We live in a pretend world wherein the outlawed stuff no longer even exists in our minds! We are blind to our lost legacy regarding plant medicines!
More Tweets



The latest hits from Drug War Records, featuring Freddie and the Fearmongers!


1. Requiem for the Fourth Amendment



2. There's No Place Like Home (until the DEA gets through with it)



3. O Say Can You See (what the Drug War's done to you and me)






front cover of Drug War Comic Book

Buy the Drug War Comic Book by the Drug War Philosopher Brian Quass, featuring 150 hilarious op-ed pics about America's disgraceful war on Americans



You have been reading an article entitled, Alternative Medicine as a Drug War Creation: a philosophical review of The Quantum Doctor by Amit Goswami, published on March 14, 2020 on AbolishTheDEA.com. For more information about America's disgraceful drug war, which is anti-patient, anti-minority, anti-scientific, anti-mother nature, imperialistic, the establishment of the Christian Science religion, a violation of the natural law upon which America was founded, and a childish and counterproductive way of looking at the world, one which causes all of the problems that it purports to solve, and then some, visit the drug war philosopher, at abolishTheDEA.com. (philosopher's bio; go to top of this page)